Sympa list alias cn cannot contain '@'

Description

In Sympa plugin we are forced to store in cn the global email of the list. It's mandatory for sympa which hosts several mail domains.

It's a FusionDirectory issue, Openldap could contain '@'

Distribution Name and Version

on debian stretch

FusionDirectory Version

ii  fusiondirectory-plugin-sympa                  1.2-2~jenkinsbuild788                        all          sympa plugin for FusionDirectory
ii  fusiondirectory-plugin-sympa-schema           1.2-2~jenkinsbuild788                        all          LDAP schema for FusionDirectory sympa plugin

Plugin with the defect

plugin-sympa

PHP version used

Origin of php packages

apt-cache policy php
php:
  Installé : 1:7.0+49
  Candidat : 1:7.0+49
 Table de version :
 *** 1:7.0+49 500
        500 http://ftp.fr.debian.org/debian stretch/main amd64 Packages
        100 /var/lib/dpkg/status

Steps to Reproduce

I insert an entry (with LDIF) with cn=list@list.domain.org I want to edit the entry , FD tell me that cn contains forbidden caracters

Expected behavior:

I should edit an entry with a CN with an @ inside

Actual behavior: Error : cn contain unauthorized caracters

Reproduces how often: always ( test 2 times)

assigned to @bmortier

added PJ1802-0188 plugin-sympa labels

please use the template as mentionned into our contributor guidelines https://gitlab.fusiondirectory.org/fusiondirectory/fd/blob/1.3-dev/CONTRIBUTING.md to rewrite your bug report with mode detail

Cheers

added 5m of time spent at 2018-04-05

changed the description

hello,

@gallak which part of the sympa plugin are you talking about ? could you add a screenshot to show where is the issue

Cheers

added 5m of time spent at 2018-04-05

see the error message, the value of "nom" is dsi.lyon@lists.irstea.fr, if '@' is removed entry is successfully modified

changed title from on Sympa plugin cn couldn't contains '@' to Sympa list alias cn cannot contain '@'

changed the description

just to explain my case

• LDAP entry are created by sympa system , ldap template used by sympa system could be adapted so I set the CN with the [list]@[domain]
• Sympa could manage several domain : https://sympa-community.github.io/manual/customize/basics-configuration.html

So I could have the following case : I have the list dsi.lyon@lists.schtroumpf.peyo but I could have dsi.lyon@lists.smurf.peyo if cn contain only dsi.lyon, postfix and sympa system couldn't determine which mail domain to apply

By the way I shouldn't be able to modify those entry becasue there are created and maintain by Sympa BUT I could modify "Partage" Information If I have to hide those list in the global Catalog.

Even If I modified the partage Tab I have the same Error : Le champ 'Nom' contient des caractères invalides!

But in fact If openldap allow "@" why Fd don't ?

But in fact If openldap allow "@" why Fd don't ?

Because FD tries to make sure only sane data is inserted in the LDAP.

I will change the cn field to a mail address one then.

created branch 5804-sympa-list-alias-cn-cannot-contain

mentioned in commit a048062b

added To Be Tested fixes-merged labels

added 30m of time spent at 2018-04-09

It's ok thanks !

closed